I found the following series of articles on the Vigil Code blog to be really useful:
- Ubuntu Server Initial Security - Quick Secure Setup Part I
- UFW with Fail2ban - Quick Secure Setup Part II
- Using AppArmor - Quick Secure Setup Part III.
Security-Enhanced (SE) Linux
- Red Hat Enterprise Linux 6, Security-Enhanced Linux User Guide.
- Note: this "article"/section is mainly notes based on this reference. This is a r-e-a-l-l-y good bit of documentation!
- Managing Red Hat Enterprise Linux, D J Walsh, K MacMilan.
- Note: this "article"/section is mainly notes based on this reference.
- The SELinux Notebook, 4th edition.
- Note: this "article"/section is mainly notes based on this reference.
- Discretionary access control, Wikipedia.
- Mandatory access control, Wikipedia.
- Principle of Least Privilege, Wikipedia.
- Linux Security Modules, Wikipedia.
- SELinux concepts, Android Docs.
- SE Linux Colouring Booko, RedHat.
- SE Linux Saves: Examples where SE Linux prevent exploits.
Linux without the SE
The Linux kernel controls that access that a process has to resources. In the standard Linux Discrtionary Access Controll (DAC) this is does by assigning users and resources to groups. Processes are given the same group and user IDs as the user that started the process. The process can then access a resource if it shares either the same user or group ID with the resource, or if the resource is "public".
I.e., a process accesses a resource based on the resource access bits:
- If the resource available to anyone, the the process can access it,
- Otherwise if the process and resource are in the same group then the the process can access it,
- Otherwies if the process and resource are owned by the same user, the process can access it,
- Otherwise the process cannot access the resource.
This is called a security policy. The policy is the set of rules used to make access control decisions.
Therefore, access to system resources must be set by the system admin, who will decide which
users belong to which groups and which system resources belong to which group (and user). However,
the system is discretionary
in the sense that a subject with a certain access permission is capable of passing that permission (perhaps indirectly) on to any other subject [Ref].
This discretionary access means that the system admin is not totally in control of who accesses what. For example, Bob can change the group associated with a file he owns and suddenly give a different set of individuals the right to read/write/execute that file. This is not in the system admin's control. Bob has been able to make to make a policy decision!
The main RedHat article referenced [Ref], describes some of the disadvantages in more detail. In summary they are:
- Processes' access is based on users' access: the kernel can not distinguish applications from users,
- Processes can change security properties: discretionary access control. Processes can escape security policy!
- Only 2 privilege levels, user and root: too simplistic and no way to enforce "least-privilege" (i.e., a process should be given only those privileges essential for it to perform its work) [Ref]
Summary of terminology:
- Security policy is the set of rules used to make access control decisions.
- Discretionary access means that a subject with a certain access permission is capable of passing that permission on.
- Least-privilege describes a security mindset that states that a process should be given only those privileges essential for it to perform its work.
SELinux: A Bird's Eye View
SELinux stands for Security Enhanced Linux. It is built on years of the NSA's security research and is an application of their Flash security architecture, implemented as part of the Linux Security Module (LSM) framework. It adds Manditory Access Controll (MAC) to Linux:
...With mandatory access control, this security policy is centrally controlled by a security policy administrator; users do not have the ability to override the policy ... By contrast, discretionary access control ... allows users the ability to make policy decisions and/or assign security attributes. ... MAC-enabled systems allow policy administrators to implement organization-wide security policies. Under MAC (and unlike DAC), users cannot override or modify this policy, either accidentally or intentionally ... in principle ...
Most interestingly, for me at least, Android uses SELinux (since 4.3) [Ref] which means that it is a very heavily used and "industry-leading" security measure. If you're going to work in the guts of Android, a little knowledge of SELinux goes a long way... hence why I'm trying to learn a little about it.
So, a more secure Linux: access control is mandatory (default denial - anything not explicitly allowed is denied), more fine grained (no longer just root and not-root) and also implements the principle of least-privilege.
There are thee forms of access control, the only one I've made notes on is Type Enforcement (TE), which is the primary SELinux mechanism.
The basic, 30k foot view of SELinux operation is this... Whenever a process accesses a file (this could be disk-based, a socket or shared memory, for example) or some other resource, this is intercepted in the kernel by SELinux. It will check all of the rules in the security policy and if the rules allow it access is granted, otherwise it is denied. The same is true when a user attempts to start a process. Note though that it runs after the built in Linux DAC. If the DAC blocks it SELinux won't even get a look in.
The SELinux Parlance
Cribbed almost verbatim from:
|User||Linux users mapped 1-to-1 to SELinux users.|
|Roles||Gateway between user and process. Roles defines which users can access which processes.|
|Subject||Person, process, or device. Anything that can affect an object.|
|Object||Anything that can be acted upon. E.g. file.|
|Permissions||Actions that a subject can perform on an object are the subject's permissions.|
|Domain||Domains are for Subjects. Security context associated with a process: it tells the process what it can and can't do.|
|Type||Types are for Objects: Dictates the objects purpose.|
|Policy||Set of rules used to make access control decisions.|
|Type Enforcement (TE)||Where a process running within a particular domain can perform only certain operations on certain types of objects.|
SELinux can be run in one of three modes:
- Enforcing: Policy is actively enforced.
- Permissive: Policy is not enforced but violations are still logged. Good for debug.
- Disabled: Not running :(
You can check what mode you're in by running either of the commands
All processes and files have a security context. A security context defines the security settings applied to a subject (person, process, or device). I guess the entire set of security contexts applied to everything in a system constitutes the security policy.
Security context: security settings applied to a person, process or device (aka "object").
The SELinux security context (aka "(security) label") is applied via a label associated with every user, process and resource. To put it another way, we can say that the rights of a process depend on it's security context. A security context is defined as follows:
type is used for type enforcement (TE), the role and level fields I will
Access is only allowed between types via the security policy and every process and resources used by that processes must have a security context (remember denial by default).
A "domain" is a little bit of jargon you'll hear a lot: The security context associated with a process is called the processes' domain.
When a type is associated with a process, it defines what processes (or domains) the SELinux user (the subject) can access.
When a type is associated with an object, it defines what access permissions the SELinux user has to that object.
So... we label all of our resources and all of our subjects and then define rules which say which subjects can do what with which objects.
Get SELinux Running On Ubuntu?
- Android Security Internals, chapter 12.
The SELinux Ubuntu Setup
Okay, to do this I am going to follow the Debian tutorial as the Ubuntu one points to it.
Following the instructions went pretty well. I now have SELinux running in permissive mode on my desktop:
sudo apt-get install selinux-basics selinux-policy-default auditd sudo cp ~/Downloads/_load_selinux_policy /usr/share/initramfs-tools/scripts/init-bottom update-initramfs -u sudo update-initramfs -u selinux-activate sudo selinux-activate sudo reboot now sudo check-selinux-installation sudo audit2why -al
The last command
audit2what -al outputs a shed load of denial messages. Unfortunately
that's where the first references Debian setup tutorial ends.
In an earlier paragraph we talked about Linux users being mapped 1-to-1 onto SELinux users. Let's see what this new setup has configured for us...
~$ sudo semanage login -l Login Name SELinux User MLS/MCS Range Service __default__ unconfined_u SystemLow-SystemHigh * root unconfined_u SystemLow-SystemHigh * system_u system_u SystemLow-SystemHigh *
We can also see what roles exist:
~$ seinfo -r Roles: 14 auditadm_r dbadm_r guest_r staff_r user_r logadm_r object_r secadm_r sysadm_r system_r webadm_r xguest_r nx_server_r unconfined_r
We can also see the security contexts in terns of rolls and types that users a labelled with:
~$ id -Z unconfined_u:unconfined_r:unconfined_t:SystemLow-SystemHigh
Remember when we said a security context looked like "
Well, here is the only security context in our system. The user
has the roll
unconfined_r, with a type
So, have our files been labelled as the tutorial claimed? Lets see...
~$ ls -lZ total 84 drwxrwxr-x. 3 jh jh unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:SystemLow 4096 Feb 3 2017 Android drwxrwxr-x. 3 jh jh unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:SystemLow 4096 Feb 3 2017 AndroidStudioProjects drwxrwxr-x. 2 jh jh unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:SystemLow 4096 May 16 19:57 bin drwxr-xr-x. 10 jh jh unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:SystemLow 4096 Aug 29 17:34 Desktop drwxr-xr-x. 4 jh jh unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:SystemLow 4096 May 1 18:31 Documents ...
Here we see that, for example, the directory
Android has a security context
unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:SystemLow. This means that, if we are using
type enforcement (TE), any user that has the type
user_home_t or is, in fact,
unconfined_u can access the directory.
But where is all of this defined? Well, it appears the SELinux policy is compiled and exists in binary trees, which are compiled from source trees [Ref]. Binary policy files are used for performance reasons [Ref]. Doing a little grep we find this:
~$ grep -R user_home_t /etc/selinux/default/ ... /etc/selinux/default/contexts/files/file_contexts.homedirs:/home/[^/]*/.+ unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:s0 /etc/selinux/default/contexts/files/file_contexts.homedirs:/root/.+ unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:s0 ...
So, the file
file_contexts.homedirs is defining a rule that matches all direct
/home and labels them with the security context
unconfined_u:object_r:user_home_t:s0. Presumably this was compiled into a binary
policy tree, which was applied to create the default labelling of the file system when I first
setup SELinux, following the Debian tutorial referenced.
Other Linux Security Modules (LSMs)
SMACK: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smack_(software) TOMOYO AppArmor Yama
Uncomplicated Firewall (UFW)
UFW is a nice front end to the more complicated iptables firewall. It really is nice and user friendly. IPTables always looked to complicated to learn to me because I'm not a hard-core system administrator. I just want an easy to use firewall that will do a good job.
UFW is described as:
... iptables provide a complete firewall solution that is both highly configurable and highly flexible ...
... Becoming proficient in iptables takes time, and ... can be a daunting task ...
... the Uncomplicated Firewall (ufw) is a ... particularly well-suited for host-based firewalls. ufw provides ... a command-line interface for manipulating the firewall. ufw aims to provide an easy to use interface for people unfamiliar with firewall concepts, while at the same time simplifies complicated iptables commands to help an administrator who knows what he or she is doing ...
Installing And First Super Restrictive Setup
Could not be easier:
sudo apt-get install --yes ufw sudo ufw enable sudo ufw default deny incoming sudo ufw default allow outgoing sudo ufw allow ssh sudo ufw limit ssh/tcp sudo ufw status verbose
This installs UFW and sets it up to deny all incoming traffic except for SSH connections but allow all outgoing traffic.
The man page and the above links will tell you pretty much everything you need to know about UFW, but here is a quick cheat sheet and a little view into some of the more complicated command line options.
|Deny All Incoming:||
|Allow All Outgoing:||
|Allow SSH Incoming:||
|Rate Limit (SSH):||
|Allow Protocol/Port Range:||
|Allow Specific IP Incoming:||
|Allow SSH from IP range:||
|Show Numbered Rules:||
|Get App Info::||
A little note on how to read some of the more complicated command lines. When you see something like this:
ufw deny proto tcp to any port 80
Read it as "
ufw, deny proto tcp to any, port 80". I.e., do not read it as
denying tcp "to any port". It is denying tcp to any address on the host using port 80.
The reason it reads like this is that on a mulihomed
you might only want to ban on a specific IP, so you might write
ufw deny proto tcp to xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx port 80,
When you see commands like "
ufw allow OpenSSH", the "
bit is an "app", which is just a name which UFW maps to a title, description, port and
The app definitions reside in
/etc/ufw/applications.d. Let's say I have a server
that I have build called JEHServ and I would like to be able to write something like:
ufw allow JEHServ". To accomplish this create the file
/etc/ufw/applications.d/jeh-serv with the following contents:
title = JEHTech server, a silly example description=A really long description about JEHTech server ports=12345/tcp|4321|99,105:110/udp
The only "complicated bit" is the
ports. For the ports you can use
a pipe delimited sequence of port numbers, ranges and protocols as shown.
After creating this file you will need to force UFW to re-read it. Type
- Fail2Ban Manual, Fail2Ban Wiki.
- Fail2Ban Command Cheat Sheet, Fail2Ban Wiki.
- How To Protect SSH with Fail2Ban on Ubuntu 14.04 , DigitalOcean.
- System: Monitoring the fail2ban log, The Art Of Web.
- UFW with Fail2ban - Quick Secure Setup Part II, Vigil Code blog.
- Using Fail2ban with Nginx and UFW, Johnny Chadda in Technology, August 4, 2014
Fail2Ban is a log parser that monitors a set of logs for messages that look "suspicious", and then uses those messages to ban IP addresses (i.e., add a firewall rule to block that IP). So if a server prints out an error message that contains the client IP address, Fail2Ban can be configured to detect that message, extract the host IP and add a firewall rule to block that IP, if for example, the message is logged more than 10 times in 1 second. The ban usually is not permanent.
|Set log level:||
|Un-ban an IP||
|Test A Jail Regex:||
Jails, Filters & Actions
Jails define the conditions that will lead an IP address to be banned by associating a filter with an action.
The filter is just a set of regular expressions which are used to extract the IP address out of log messages. The action is self explanatory: usually adds a rule to the firewall but can do anything like send emails etc.
Jails are found in
/etc/fail2ban/jail.conf. Don't modify this file! Put new changes
/etc/fail2ban/jail.local. Any settings in this file override those in the
.conf file. You do not need to copy the
.conf file... just
insert the changes you wish to make into the
.local file. Think of it as an
inheritance relationship. The
.local file inherits everything from the
file and then applies specific overrides and extensions. An alternative way to specify a jail is
to add it, in its own file, to
Actions are found in
/etc/fail2ban/action.d/. Filters are found in
The default action for everything is to ban an IP address. The default firewall being used is
iptables. Note: if you are using UFW you will have to reconfigure Fail2Ban to use UFW.
Note, that to begin with all jails are disabled by default. You should only enable
the jails that are required for you system. For example, a basic system with only an SSH server
running, might only have this in
[sshd] enabled = true [sshd-ddos] enabled = true
Because these settings override or add to the existing settings in
all we need to specify for SSH... all the other settings like the filter and actions have already
been defined: the jail only needs enabling.
Working With UFW
By default, Fail2Ban will use iptables to block IP addresses. What I found was that, at least on
Debian (9.4), that it still worked, i.e., IP addresses were still banned, but the ban status
did not show up when executing a
ufw status command. To get it working with UFW
all you need to do is add the following to your
[DEFAULT] banaction = ufw
This works by overriding the default ban action because of the file
that is nicely provided for us :)
To go into a little more detail have a look at
you will see the following definition:
action = %(action_)s
This is the default action that will be taken when fail2ban bans an IP address. It is set to
a macro expansion. In this case it expands the macro "
If we look at this macro we can see it defined as this:
action_ = %(banaction)s[name=%(__name__)s, bantime="%(bantime)s", port="%(port)s", protocol="%(protocol)s", chain="%(chain)s"]
It is itself a string that contains multiple macros that are in turn expanded. The most important macro,
if we want to do anything other than the default ban action is, "
by overriding this variable we have cause the default action to use UFW.
One thing you might be wondering is why each expansion has an "s" appended at the end, like for example,
on the line
%(action_)s. What does the trailing "s" do? It is there because Fail2Ban uses
Python string interpolation
and the trailing "s" means that the variable is converted to a string using the Python
Sending Email Alerts
There are other interesting actions available that we can find, including "
action_mwl". We'd want to use
this if we not only want to ban IP addresses but also send the server admin an email about the event. To use this rule, we
simply modify the
DEFAULT section of our
jail.local jail as follows:
[DEFAULT] destemail = email@example.com sender = firstname.lastname@example.org banaction = ufw action = %(action_mwl)s
There is one little caveat you will have to address. Sendmail, which is the mail client fail2ban will
use by default, will want a fully qualified domain name as the hostname. It gets this by indirectly looking up
/etc/hosts file (via OS APIs). So you need to change the following line in
To something like:
127.0.0.1 my.client-name.com localhost
Now sendmail won't barf on startup and on trying to send mail! You want a real, or at least a unique, domain name so that if you have different servers sending events to you, you can identify which server sent it.
There is also the option of hardcoding the FQDN in
/etc/mail/sendmail.mc, but you will still
have to modify
/etc/hosts anwyay [Ref].
Define Your Own Ban
Lets say I have a service that I have created that dumps error messages to a log file. Define
the service in
[my-silly-server] enabled = true port = 1234 logpath = /var/log/my-silly-server-log bantime = ... findtime = ... maxretry = ...
This tells Fail2Ban to create and enable a jail called "my-silly-server" for a
service listening to port 1234 that writes to the log file
Other configuration options like
can also be specified. The value for
maxretry specifies the number of failures that have to
occur in the last
findtime seconds in order to ban the IP. The parameter
dictates how many seconds the ban is in place for.
However, what this doesn't tell Fail2Ban is what log messages it should scan for. To do that you
must add a
.conf file with the same name as the jail to the directory
So in this case the file would be
/etc/fail2ban/filter.d/my-silly-server.conf. That file must contain
[Definition] failregex = Some error from <HOST> The client <HOST> sent yet another regex-defined error
The Developing Filters section of the Fail2Ban docs contains much more detailed information.
In the above,
failregex, defines the regular expressions that Fail2Ban will match against
each line of the log file specified. The "
<HOST>" part of the expression
is a special Fail2Ban regex that will match any IP address or host name. This will be used in the
ban action. Thus, in the above, should the log contain "Some error from 184.108.40.206:4321",
or "The client 220.127.116.11 sent yet another regex-defined error", then the
18.104.22.168 will be blocked by adding a rule to the firewall in use.
You can test out your regex using the
fail2ban-regex as so:
fail2ban-regex /path/to/log/file /etc/fail2ban/filter.d/my-silly-server.conf [regex-to-ignore]
fail2ban-regex /path/to/log/file "a test regex"
The following is taken from this fail2ban github thread. You should set your backend for sshd jail to systemd. File-backends (like pyinotify, polling as well as auto) do montoring of the log-files only (not systemd-journals).
[sshd] backend = systemd
And for check it via fail2ban-regex you can use:
# for >= 0.10: fail2ban-regex systemd-journal sshd # or for 0.9: fail2ban-regex systemd-journal /etc/fail2ban/filter.d/sshd.conf
SECure COMPuting - Seccomp
The idea behind seccomp is to restrict the system calls that can be made from a process ... The Linux kernel has a few hundred system calls, but most of them are not needed by any given process ...
Secure Shell (SSH)
Installing the SSH client is very simple:
sudo apt-get install ssh
Once installed use
sudo systemctl status ssh to get the status of the SSH daemon. To start/stop the daemon use
sudo systemctl start/stop ssh.
For security, root access via SSH is sometimes disabled and password authentication is always disabled (prefer public/private keys). You can also run the SSH daemon on a non standard port. Especially useful is to setup Fail2Ban to monitor system log files for suspicious SSH activity (see above).
The SSH daemon configuration file is located at
/etc/ssh/sshd_config. To disable root loging grep for the line containing "
and make sure it reads:
To disable password authentication grep for the line containing "
PasswordAuthentication" and make sure it reads:
You should also disable PAM:
You may also want to use
LogLevel VERBOSE, so that the key fingerprint of SSH keys used for login are recorded.
Once you have made the changes you want type:
sudo systemctrl restart ssh
To setup a new public/private key pair with, at the time of writing, some future proofing in the key length, use the following:
ssh-keygen -t rsa -b 3072 -C "A meaningful description" -f file-name-for-your-key-pair
Make sure you enter a secure password for your key. I.e., use upper and lower case as well as numbers at the very least with a reasonable length. Two new files will have
been created in the directory from which your ran the
Move these to a secure location and keep the private key secret! The minute this key is compromised, so is your server.
You can have as many key pairs as you like, probably for each user of your system. You will then need to add these to your SSH server's allowed list. Note, never do this as root. To add a key to the SSH servers allowed list do:
cat file-name-for-your-key-pair.pub >> ~/.ssh/authorized_keys
.ssh directory does not exist you can create it using
mkdir ~/.ssh && chmod 700 ~/.ssh. If the
did not exist make sure to has
600 permissions. Lastly move your key file into the
One thing you might notice is that the key file is in the user's local directory. This can be fine if you want users to be able to dictate who can login to the system,
but can also be a massive security hole! To overcome this you can edit
/etc/ssh/sshd_config and make sure the key
AuthorizedKeyFile reads as:
Where the "
%u" expands during connection setup to the user-name of the user trying to log in.
To use a specific key to log into the SSH server use:
ssh -i /path/to/private-key user-name@server_ip
- Quick-Tip: SSH Tunneling Made Easy, by Frank Wiles
- SSH tunnel, SSH Achademy.
- SSH Port Forwarding Example, SSH Achademy.
-f Requests ssh to go to background just before command execution.
Specifies that the given port on the local (client) host is to be forwarded to the given host and port on the remote side. This works by allocating a socket to listen to port on the local side, optionally bound to the specified bind_address. Whenever a connection is made to this port, the connection is forwarded over the secure channel, and a connection is made to host port hostport from the remote machine. Port forwardings can also be specified in the configuration file. IPv6 addresses can be specified by enclosing the address in square brackets. Only the superuser can forward privileged ports. By default, the local port is bound in accordance with the GatewayPorts setting. However, an explicit bind_address may be used to bind the connection to a specific address. The bind_address of -localhost- indicates that the listening port be bound for local use only, while an empty address or -*- indicates that the port should be available from all interfaces.
-N Do not execute a remote command. This is useful for just forwarding ports (protocol version 2 only).
This diagram will help explain it:
This is why the following works [Ref]:
ssh -N -f email@example.com -L 2000:server.com:25 -N # ^ ^ ^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ # ^ ^ ^^^^^^^^ Host port 2000 is forwarded to port 25 on remote server server.com. # ^ ^ ^^^^^^^^ # ^ ^ User on remote server. # ^ ^ # ^ Go into background. # ^ # Do not execute a remote command.